Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | copycatchiller's commentslogin

Hi Peter - thank you for this! I am from Mexico and working on STEM OPT on an expired F1 (can't travel), lost H1B lottery two years in a row now.

Are there good reasons for Mexicans on STEM OPT who intend to get a GC to keep entering H1B lottery, instead of getting a TN visa and attempting change of status? Are there other avenues?

Thank you!


There's a pervasive misunderstanding that someone in TN status cannot pursue a green card and must be in H-1B status to do. This is just not true.


You can technically apply for a green card but border guards can and do use it as evidence that you don’t intend to stay “temporarily” and deny your TN as a result.

They can reevaluate your TN status at every crossing, and there are many stories of this happening to people returning from holiday when I was at microsoft. The TN is efficient to get but has its downsides.


For anyone curious like I was, Trade NAFTA Visa

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TN_status


That's correct so when pursuing a green card while in TN status, the applicant should only travel internationally after commencing the green card process on an advance parole travel document (not on a TN) or get his or her green card through a process abroad, called immigrant visa processing. An applicant for a green card in TN status should never seek admission in TN status if he or she is the beneficiary of a pending or approved I-140 petition unless he or she is immigrant visa processing and only then after consulting with an immigration attorney to understand the issues, process, and risks of doing so.


Calibre is my favourite product - been using it for more than a decade now. So happy to see it top the front page here.


yes, but there are also things done because "they have always been done this way." That's also a dangerous pattern imo.


Democratizing the spread of ideas can help prevents privileged groups from controlling discourse. In the past you were subject to what you could broadcast on radio/tv or publish in print -- many of these options were out of reach for POCs, women, ppl in poverty.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: