That's fair. Here on HN, tptacek writes negatively about Nadim surprisingly often. I do think it's bullying, though you're right that it's more subtle than his behavior on Twitter.
dang is great. I just wish we had a bit less negativity.
--
Finally, a brief history for readers who dont know yet:
* Cryptocat v1 was a cat themed anonymous chat webapp with very broken homebrew encryption. It was basically Nadim's crypto learning project as far as I can tell when he was ~20 years old.
* Snowden allegedly used it at some point. Oops.
* Crypto experts reviewed it and found significant flaws. Tptacek wrote about how terrible it was, how JS crypto is Considered Harmful, how amateurs shouldn't write crypto because they could get someone killed, etc
* Cryptocat v2 a desktop chat app using Axolotl / Signal Protocol for e2e encryption. Nadim is a phd student now. It's a new and totally separate codebase.
tldr; there's no reason to assume that Cryptocat v2 sucks in the ways the original did. It may be totally sound.
(I have no involvement w the project and have not reviewed the code.)
dang is great. I just wish we had a bit less negativity.
--
Finally, a brief history for readers who dont know yet:
* Cryptocat v1 was a cat themed anonymous chat webapp with very broken homebrew encryption. It was basically Nadim's crypto learning project as far as I can tell when he was ~20 years old.
* Snowden allegedly used it at some point. Oops.
* Crypto experts reviewed it and found significant flaws. Tptacek wrote about how terrible it was, how JS crypto is Considered Harmful, how amateurs shouldn't write crypto because they could get someone killed, etc
* Cryptocat v2 a desktop chat app using Axolotl / Signal Protocol for e2e encryption. Nadim is a phd student now. It's a new and totally separate codebase.
tldr; there's no reason to assume that Cryptocat v2 sucks in the ways the original did. It may be totally sound.
(I have no involvement w the project and have not reviewed the code.)