Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are a number of misplaced points in this article, but I will focus on two.

UEFI, properly implemented, is a huge improvement over old BIOS. It isn't required to be 'locked', and I have never encountered a Windows laptop or desktop that didn't not allow you to disable secure boot within the BIOS. I am not as familiar with Apple hardware so I will not comment on that.

UEFI and it GUID partition layout is superior to traditional BIOS. I develop within embedded systems that rely on GUID partitions to provide granularity of storage. One current system I support has 34 partitions, to support redundancy, safe image updates, and soft recovery.

With UEFI on the desktop, you can implement the same strategies.

So those are two statements in the post that I found to be misleading, if not outright wrong.

On the hardware front, yes, current era consumer laptops have become completely sealed boxes. If you want to own a laptop that can be upgraded and maintained, you need to buy either a gaming or enterprise laptop.

For most people, and enterprise laptop is only going to be slightly more expensive than a consumer grade device. It is not going to be as slim and 'sexy'. It t will likely have useful ports down the side.

On desktops, as long as you are buying a full sized desktop, I have not seen any (yet) that are not completely equipped with appropriate connectors and cabling to support upgrades.

I have seen 'mini' systems that are completely soldered down, but that is the price you pay for small. Connectors consume real estate.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: