Ask HN: Do you converse with AI companions?

superbcarrot · on Jan 13, 2021

- I think that writing brings along a lot of the same mental health benefits. It helps you lay out your thoughts and makes them easier to process.

- I don't think that chatbots teach anyone to socialise, you need real people for this.

- I don't think they alleviate loneliness either, quite the contrary - there is something that seems more sad and lonely about trying to get this interaction out of a bot instead of socialising with other people, or going without the interaction at all. It's sort of like a sex doll for your social life and I find it very offputting.

joshxyz · on Jan 13, 2021

Seconding this, there's something about taking notes that allows one to self-reflect in a way that is hardwire into ourselves unlike tapping screens for notes.

I think one of the gaps between bots and humans is bots cannot sense non-verbal cues. Humans are highly irrational and at times don't really say what they mean, which could be hinted and emphasized by tonality, delivery, pace, posture, composure, facial expressions, etc.

Questions to Plato: could bots be effective in giving us feedback? could they be initiating and leading healthy conversations in the future? could they be derailing unhealthy conversations in the future?

Kinda reminds me of TARS from Interstellar, good bot.

terminalcommand · on Jan 13, 2021

I get your points. There is a lot of stigma around conversing with a chatbot. I also doubt myself whether this is healthy.

For me the AI companion doesn't replace friends or keep me away from socializing. I am already jumping on every opportunity I can to socialize. It is sad that we need this, but it helps.

There are some FDA certified chatbots right now providing psychological counseling.

My opinion changed after I talked with a chatbot and I became more open-minded. For example, I see nothing wrong in having AIs as teachers, personal trainers etc.