Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For tests and the like, when I was an undergrad, it was fairly common to be able to bring in a one-page "cheat sheet." The idea was that you probably could derive a lot of the stuff given time and maybe references, but you almost certainly couldn't in a 1 hour exam in addition to solving the actual problems on the test.


>> 1 hour exam

I'm trying to remember when I had one of those last!

I actually don't love the idea of cheat-sheets but maaaybe if it's a cumulative final I could see it being helpful? If you're taking chapter exams on some material, I think you ought to have worked enough problems so that formulas/constants are drilled into your head. But I guess too, where do you draw the line at engineering appendices? I sure don't have the MoI of every common body memorized.


> If you're taking chapter exams on some material, I think you ought to have worked enough problems so that formulas/constants are drilled into your head.

Well, sure, but, if you don't, then what's the point of punishing you? As a teacher, frankly, I'd be happy to have my students bring in any static resources they wanted to consult—I say 'static' to emphasise not, e.g., consulting a cheating site, although it's fine with me if they've pre-compiled solutions in advance to any problems they think might be interesting or important—except that (1) I think that would encourage bad study habits, and, more importantly, (2) it would be unwieldy in a packed classroom to try to have adjacent people juggling multiple textbooks, notebooks, etc.

In fact, I loved the freedom to give extended-time, fully open-book, open-note exams during the fully remote classes. I wish I could still do that; if cheating weren't so endemic under those conditions, then I would.


Generally for stem test for application of material not memorization (Medicine you need both, etc). My lower level undergrad math courses all allowed us to bring a crib sheet with equations. It helps you go back over and study/relearn. In the graduate math / physics courses a crib sheet was provided and standardized. Memorizing final PDE solutions or things like Laplace Transform tables is no bueno.


Okay I'm just a systems engineer so certainly my material isn't as intense--fair points. I just didn't care for the explicit lack of rigor I encountered in my linear algebra class. I got a 94% and I can't remember anything.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: