If you're already building on AWS or Google Cloud, you should use Route 53 or Cloud Domains, respectively, so you can leverage your existing IAM policies and avoid putting trust in other organizations unnecessarily.

Otherwise, Gandi is a solid choice.

From another perspective, decoupling your domain from your cloud host means if things go wrong with your hosting you can still migrate to another host with a DNS change. I feel like I'd be more likely to have an issue with a hosting provider than a DNS registrar, but maybe that's a bad assumption.

Route 53 is a Gandi reseller :) (I don’t know about Cloud Domains)

In the early days Route 53 used Gandi exclusively, but now they use Amazon Registrar for at least .com, .org, .net.

I assume Cloud Domains uses Google Domains as the registrar.

Sounds like Amazon's relationship with Square. For the use cases they havent had their own engineers write integrations with their primary payment processor to cover, lean on the work of a payments focused company.

I use them too. Great customer service with a real and competent person on the line right away. Decided to go with them after some searching. I was getting off Google and they had an actual office and pictures of the people who worked there on their website. Some of their marketing is a bit corny but have had great service over the past few years.

support isn't that good if you ask me. when I had a problem with my account and they couldn't resolve it, it took quite some time to get my domain back under control.

Yup using them too, can't fault them. On the rare occasion I've needed support its been quick.

I moved my domains to Porkbun over the last year and I’ve been pretty happy with them so far.

They haven't screwed me so far.

My limitation for domains is SRS, I need to be able to redirect email to my inbox without paying for an additional service and without emails arriving as spam because of DMARC. Because of this I ended up at Google, which I don't really like because of their nonexistent support.

What's the new hotness if SRS is a requirement?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sender_Rewriting_Scheme

I have been happy with Cloudflare's domain system so far. I also use Namecheap still.

I've been using Namesilo for years now. Never had a single complaint.

Also recommend Namesilo. Always good pricing for renewals. The website is a bit outdated, but I prepay for 10 years and rarely have to deal with it.

Dynadot is who I use, prices are just as cheap as NameCheap, but they have a much better website and allow you to "name taste" - return the domain name within 72 hours if you change your mind for a refund.

It doesn't matter, since they all only handle a limited subset of the new TLDs you'll end up having to use one you don't like anyway.

Unless you can come up with a best list for each TLD.

I've been using PorkBun for a couple of years now. It reminds me of Namecheap in their earlier years. A much simpler UI, great support and decent/fair prices.

Used to talk to the guy that founded them, he was a stand up chap. Great to see they're still around. They used to be a ResellerClub/DirectI reseller but like me (also ran a registrar) they were moving away due to the crappy service being provided.

I don't know about hotness, but I always use name.com and it hasn't given me any problems

I've been using iwantmyname.com for ages and love them.

hover.com. Consistent, straightforward, good customer service.