Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is legal for a person to do, right? Why should it not be legal for an LLM to do?

AFAIK but IANAL, I can go look at a solution in a GPLed library and then code that solution in my proprietary code base. As in, "oh, I see, the used a hash map for that and a list of this, and locked at this point. I'll code up something similar". As along as you don't "copy the code" you're fine.

Am I wrong?

Is it just a matter of scale? (hey there LLM, re-write all of OpenOffice into ClosedOffice).



> This is legal for a person to do, right? Why should it not be legal for an LLM to do?

Because humans are human. We are rewarded extra super duper rights that inanimate things, such as a computer program, are not rewarded.

I think we should therefore work to demonstrate this is not the case, which is very hard to do. No idea why we would work under the absolutely insane, never-before-seen assumption that computer programs deserve human rights. I don't know where this line of reasoning started, or why, but at it's core it's so unbelievably preposterous (and against the very wellbeing of mankind).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: