Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"No additional cost for private registration" is badly required in the industry, and glad to see Google take the lead.

Also, there should be an option to 301 redirect your blogspot blog to a domain held by Google. Lots of bloggers have outgrown their .blogspot.com blogs.



Gandi (https://www.gandi.net/) is quite well-known for having free private domain registration.


And unlike many such services, they still list you as the owner of the domain; they just mask the email/address/phone information.


I'm not sure if this is a positive or negative comment, but I'll explain why they do that.

There are two main ways to mask domain name whois information: 1) go through a proxy service, i.e., a company buys the domain under their name and gives you control, or 2) effectively use another entity's contact information with the exception of name, which is what Gandi does.

a) is rather risky to both parties. You do not own the domain, but another entity does. If you somehow lose the domain name or the entity holding the name goes under, you won't be able to get it back because it technically never belonged to you. The holder is also now legally responsible for the domain name.

b) is a much safer route with the constraint that your name must be attached to the domain name. This makes it so you always remain responsible for and the registrant of the domain name. It is yours.


> I'm not sure if this is a positive or negative comment

Very much positive, for exactly the reasons you specified.


Love Gandi. I can't say if their customer service is good, though, because I have yet to have any issues.


Could you provide the exact link for this? I have looked to no avail.


It's an included service when you use them to manage your domain names.

https://www.gandi.net/domain/whois/

http://wiki.gandi.net/en/domains/private-registration

http://wiki.gandi.net/en/contacts/privatewhois

From the home page, it's at the bottom of the green box under "Every domain name includes".


Well, the subtlety is that only applies to domain registered for "personal", not "business", use.

Gandi support used to be the best. Now that domain isn't they core and only business, support quality is falling. Fast.

I have an old account. And some point they migrated my old account. And now my domain is flagged as a business type domain, which it isn't. It is lock as they changed it themselves. When I've contacted them, they did not want to fix it. They messed up, denies it and won't fix it. So, for me, not so great customer support ... Anyway, I'm moving away, domain by domain.


Hello from Gandi. The scenario you're describing sounds like a result of a change we made in 2006 when we added a new domain contact type. If so, we _can_ do something about it. Either way, we're not in the habit of messing up and refusing to fix it. If you have a ticket number from your previous exchange, we could go from there, or you can email me directly (aj@).



http://register4less.com/ offers free private registration. No affiliation, just a happy customer.


Actually, namesilo offers free whois privacy. http://www.namesilo.com/


Hover do this (& I highly recommend them)


Actually 1&1 has been offering that free private registration for a while. I switched from GoDaddy a few years ago.


I paid $8/yr to register my domains with 1&1 now they've upped the price to $15/yr. Fuck them.


I wonder if that includes private from Google's internal uses?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: