Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've seen one or two of these. I've also not seen any really successful or compelling products come out of any of them.


Pick any 2 random conventional startups, and this will be just as true.


True!

That said, my personal experience with coops is that they tend to be consensus-driven and give everyone a veto. This is a problematic model when vision is required. Works well for more readily-defined things like grocery stores or running a dorm, though.


The kinds that have management representing the coop work around that problem a bit. They have someone with vision, experience, and the ability to work through disagreements. That person normally does his or her thing with others adding opinions, votes, or whatever. The critical benefit is that such a person can step in to clear out obstacles caused by a lack of consensus.

So, even with its issues, representational democracy can be better than pure democracy so long as everyone is doing his or her part. :)


I'm the founder of this co-op - and no, it isn't consensus based. In fact, we made a point of NOT doing things by consensus!

Not all co-ops are consensus-based, in fact I'd say the majority are not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: