Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is this always an in-place upgrade, or would there be a way to do a clean install (possibly on another pc - IIRC windows licenses are per OS instance not per machine?) for free as well?


I always wonder why they never mention how the supposedly free upgrade works. From this article and the linked FAQ I get the impression that I do not qualify for free Windows 10 forever, but that I can upgrade my Windows 8.1 installations via Windows Upgrade for a year after launch, but that my Windows license is not generally upgraded to a Windows 10 license. I take this to mean that after a year and a day, when I want to reinstall, I cannot use my current key to install some Windows 10 install image, but have to use my Win8.1 image, and since the year for free upgrades has passed, I cannot upgrade that install to Windows 10 anymore.

Or are there other infos out about this very typical scenario among IT people?


I seem to remember Paul Thurrott saying that the free upgrade window is open for a year, not that your license is only good for a year of use.


Yes, it seems Thurrott has some info: https://www.thurrott.com/windows/windows-10/3898/a-few-more-...

Basically it seems to be that MS saves the info in the Windows store and lets you reinstall a fresh Windows 10 if you upgraded. If this information is correct.


The rule of thumb is that if it can activate it can upgrade.


Yes, but say I upgrade my Win8.1 during the free year. In two years time I want to reinstall. Will there be an option to a. download some Windows 10 installation media so I can do a fresh install, or do I b. always have to first install Win8.1?

If it's a, is my Win8.1 license key valid? Did the MS activation server get the memo that I upgraded during the free year? If it is b, will the upgrade from Win8.1 to 10 still be free after the first year, or not? I already upgraded my license once,but do they keep track of this? Can I still activate? Or does it count as a new try to upgrade after the free year?


Windows 8 can be reverted to a freshly installed state from within, so I assume 10 can do that too.


That's not the same thing as starting on a fresh, new, formatted hard drive.


I was looking for this to, their faq (http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-faq) neglects to answer the question.

On the community discussion it's been asked without an official response yet (http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-...).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: